MASTECTOMY VS CONSERVATIVE SURGERY IN CARCINOMA BREAST
Main Article Content
Keywords
Breast cancer, mastectomy, breast-conserving surgery, oncological outcomes, quality of life, recurrence
Abstract
Background
‘Breast cancer is one of the most common malignancies among women, with surgical intervention being a cornerstone of treatment’. Mastectomy and breast-conserving surgery (BCS) are widely practiced surgical options. While both approaches have shown comparable survival outcomes, differences in recurrence rates, complications, and quality of life necessitate further exploration. This study aimed to compare the oncological outcomes, post-surgical complications, and quality of life in patients undergoing mastectomy versus ‘breast-conserving surgery for breast carcinoma’.
Methods
This retrospective cohort study was conducted at Gomal Medical College and its affiliated hospitals from January 2023 to January 2024. A total of 110 patients with histologically confirmed invasive breast carcinoma, stages I–III, were included. Patients were divided equally into two groups: 55 underwent mastectomy, and 55 underwent BCS. Data on recurrence, survival, complications, and quality of life were collected and analyzed using statistical methods. P-values <0.05 were considered significant.
Results
Local recurrence rates were slightly higher in the ‘BCS group (7.3%) compared to the mastectomy group (5.5%), though not statistically significant (P=0.67)’. Distant metastasis rates were comparable between groups. Disease-free survival and overall survival showed negligible differences, highlighting similar oncological outcomes for both approaches. Complications such as lymphedema and chronic pain were more frequent in the mastectomy group, while quality of life scores were significantly higher in the BCS group (P=0.02).
Conclusion
Both mastectomy and BCS are effective surgical options for managing breast carcinoma, with comparable oncological outcomes. BCS offers the added advantage of better quality of life and cosmetic satisfaction, making it an appealing choice for eligible patients. Treatment decisions should prioritize patient preferences, tumor characteristics, and access to adjuvant therapies.
References
2. Oei, S.L., et al., Evaluation of quality of life in breast cancer patients who underwent breast-conserving surgery or mastectomy using real-world data. Breast Cancer, 2023. 30(6): p. 1008-1017.
3. Zhang, M., et al., Breast-conserving surgery is oncologically safe for well-selected, centrally located breast cancer. Annals of Surgical Oncology, 2021. 28: p. 330-339.
4. Vohra, L.M., et al., Quality of life of breast cancer survivors: a comparison of breast conserving surgery versus total mastectomy with and without immediate reconstruction: a prospective cohort study. Annals of Medicine and Surgery, 2023. 85(5): p. 1513-1517.
5. Ee, M.C.W., et al., Oncological outcomes following extreme oncoplastic breast conserving surgery (eOPBCS) for locally advanced breast cancer (LABC): A systematic review and meta-analysis. The Breast, 2024: p. 103869.
6. Liu, H. and C. Luo, Effect of breast-conserving surgery and modified radical mastectomy on quality of life of early breast cancer patients. Food Science and Technology, 2021. 42: p. e47021.
7. Fancellu, A., et al., Outcomes after breast-conserving surgery or mastectomy in patients with triple-negative breast cancer: meta-analysis. British Journal of Surgery, 2021. 108(7): p. 760-768.
8. Qin, R., et al., Survival Outcomes of Breast-Conserving Surgery Versus Mastectomy in Locally Advanced Breast Cancer Following Neoadjuvant Chemotherapy: A Meta-Analysis. Technology in Cancer Research & Treatment, 2024. 23: p. 15330338241265030.
9. Simons, J.M., et al., Disease-free and overall survival after neoadjuvant chemotherapy in breast cancer: breast-conserving surgery compared to mastectomy in a large single-centre cohort study. Breast Cancer Research and Treatment, 2021. 185: p. 441-451.
10. Gwark, S., et al., Survival after breast-conserving surgery compared with that after mastectomy in breast cancer patients receiving neoadjuvant chemotherapy. Annals of Surgical Oncology, 2023. 30(5): p. 2845-2853.
11. Christiansen, P., et al., Breast-conserving surgery or mastectomy?: impact on survival. Annals of Surgery Open, 2022. 3(4): p. e205.
12. Mohamedahmed, A.Y.Y., et al., Comparison of surgical and oncological outcomes between oncoplastic breast-conserving surgery versus conventional breast-conserving surgery for treatment of breast cancer: A systematic review and meta-analysis of 31 studies. Surgical oncology, 2022. 42: p. 101779.
13. Kim, H., et al., Survival of breast-conserving surgery plus radiotherapy versus total mastectomy in early breast cancer. Annals of surgical oncology, 2021: p. 1-9.
14. Shubeck, S., et al., Comparison of outcomes between BRCA pathogenic variant carriers undergoing breast-conserving surgery versus mastectomy. Annals of surgical oncology, 2022. 29(8): p. 4706-4713.
15. Dahlui, M., et al., Breast conserving surgery versus mastectomy: the effect of surgery on quality of life in breast cancer survivors in Malaysia. BMC Women's Health, 2023. 23(1): p. 607.
16. Song, Y.-C., et al., Breast-conserving surgery versus mastectomy for treatment of breast cancer after neoadjuvant chemotherapy. Frontiers in Oncology, 2023. 13: p. 1178230.
17. Li, S., et al., A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials comparing breast-conserving surgery and mastectomy in terms of patient survival rate and quality of life in breast cancer. International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 2024. 36(2): p. mzae043.
18. De la Cruz Ku, G., et al., Does breast-conserving surgery with radiotherapy have a better survival than mastectomy? A meta-analysis of more than 1,500,000 patients. Annals of Surgical Oncology, 2022. 29(10): p. 6163-6188.
19. Abrahimi, M.S., et al., Associated factors and survival outcomes for breast conserving surgery versus mastectomy among New Zealand women with early-stage breast cancer. International journal of environmental research and public health, 2021. 18(5): p. 2738.
Article Sidebar
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
All articles published in JPTCP are licensed under Copyright Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Dr Wasim Ahmad
Associate Professor, Department of Surgery, Gomal Medical College, Dera Ismail Khan, Pakistan
Dr Junaid Iqbal
Consultant, Department of General Surgery, Southwest Health Complex, Kohat, Pakistan
Dr Waheed Ur Rehman
District Specialist, Department of General Surgery, DHQ Hospital Miranshah, North Waziristan, Pakistan
Dr Wagma Sirshar
Resident Surgeon, Department of General Surgery, MTI Hayatabad Medical Complex, Pakistan